What Changed for FBI Employees

Historically, most FBI employees were excluded from MSPB appeal rights. When an agent or analyst faced removal or suspension, their only option was an internal DOJ or FBI process—with no ability to take the case to an independent tribunal.

Preference-eligible veterans were the narrow exception. Under 5 U.S.C. § 7511(b)(8), they could appeal certain adverse actions to the MSPB, but all others were excluded.

That changed with the FBI Whistleblower Reform Act of 2022 (Pub. L. 117-263 § 5304), which added 5 U.S.C. § 2303(d). For the first time, it allows FBI employees to:

  • Appeal a final DOJ determination or corrective-action order in a whistleblower case to the MSPB; or

  • File an Independent Right of Action (IRA) with the MSPB if 180 days pass without a final decision.

The Department of Justice implemented these rights in its final rule (Feb 2 2024), codified at 28 C.F.R. Part 27.

Bottom line:

  • Adverse actions: Only preference-eligible FBI employees have MSPB appeal rights for removals, demotions, or long suspensions.

  • Whistleblower reprisal: All FBI employees may now bring § 2303 whistleblower reprisal claims to the MSPB—after first filing internally with the DOJ’s Office of Professional Responsibility (OPR) or Office of Inspector General (OIG), and either receiving a final decision or waiting 180 days.

While narrow, this expansion represents a major breakthrough for FBI employees who’ve long been denied the procedural safeguards most federal workers enjoy.

Who Qualifies as “Preference Eligible”

“Preference-eligible” generally includes veterans and certain family members of disabled or deceased veterans who served on active duty during specified conflicts or after 9/11. Disabled veterans receiving VA benefits are also covered. Members of the Senior Executive Service (SES) are generally not preference eligible.

See 5 U.S.C. § 2108 for statutory definitions.

Preference-eligible FBI employees can appeal adverse actions like removals, demotions, or suspensions of more than 14 days to the MSPB. Non-preference employees cannot—but they can pursue whistleblower claims under § 2303.

Internal Process Still Comes First

Even with the new rights, FBI employees must exhaust the internal process before appealing externally. That means:

  • Filing the complaint internally with OPR or OIG; and

  • Either receiving a final DOJ decision or waiting 180 days without one before filing with the MSPB.

Skipping steps or missing deadlines can forfeit appeal rights. Once the internal process concludes, an MSPB appeal must generally be filed within 30 days.

An experienced federal employment lawyer can ensure every procedural requirement is met and every deadline protected.

The “Two-Track” Problem: Parkinson v. DOJ

Even for preference-eligible veterans, rights can be complex. In Parkinson v. Department of Justice, 874 F.3d 710 (Fed. Cir. 2017), the Federal Circuit held that FBI preference-eligible employees cannot raise whistleblower-reprisal defenses in an MSPB adverse-action appeal. Instead, they must bring those reprisal allegations through the separate § 2303 whistleblower process.

This means a preference-eligible employee facing removal based on alleged retaliation might need two concurrent proceedings:

  1. An MSPB appeal on the adverse action; and

  2. A § 2303 whistleblower complaint (which may also reach the MSPB under the new rules).

This complexity underscores why it’s essential to have experienced counsel coordinating both tracks strategically.

Other Limitations

  • EEO process: All FBI employees retain the right to pursue discrimination and harassment claims under the standard federal-sector EEO system.

  • USERRA claims: The MSPB and Office of Special Counsel lack jurisdiction over FBI employees’ USERRA (military-service discrimination) claims. See Erlendson v. DOJ, 2014 MSPB 61 (2014).

  • Internal due process: Even non-preference employees are entitled to some procedural protections under internal FBI regulations before adverse actions take effect.

Why Most FBI Employees Still Don’t Know This

The FBI operates under a personnel system separate from Title 5. Because of this unique framework—and limited public communication from DOJ—many employees still believe they have no MSPB rights at all.

At NSLF, we’ve seen countless agents and analysts who could have challenged unjust actions but didn’t realize they qualified until it was too late.

Why This Matters

These reforms mark an important step toward accountability and fairness in the FBI’s employment system. Even limited access to an external tribunal means:

  • Independent review outside DOJ channels

  • Access to discovery, evidence, and counsel under MSPB procedures

  • Potential remedies such as reinstatement, back pay, or attorney fees

For whistleblowers, it means a more credible avenue to report misconduct without fear of internal retaliation.

Why Choose National Security Law Firm

At National Security Law Firm, our attorneys understand the complexities of FBI and DOJ personnel systems—because many of us have worked inside them. Our team includes former federal prosecutors, JAG officers, and agency attorneys who know how to navigate both internal and external processes effectively.

We bring insider knowledge and battle-tested litigation experience to every case. Whether your issue involves an MSPB appeal, clearance suspension, or whistleblower retaliation, we fight to protect your career, your clearance, and your future.

Why NSLF:

  • 4.9-star Google reviews from clients nationwide

  • Representation of federal employees and contractors nationwide

  • Washington, D.C. headquarters — the hub of federal employment law

  • Attorneys with insider government & military experience

  • Founders who are disabled veterans committed to protecting those who serve

  • Attorney Review Board collaboration for strategic advantage on complex cases

Explore our Federal Employment Law hub

More Resources for FBI Employees

If you’re an FBI employee trying to understand your rights, these additional guides break down the details behind MSPB eligibility, appeal procedures, and whistleblower protections:

Each of these posts expands on a different aspect of FBI employment law and links directly to your legal rights under 5 U.S.C. §§ 2108, 2303(d), and 7511(b)(8). Together, they form your complete guide to understanding how to fight back against unjust discipline, retaliation, and clearance-related actions inside the Bureau.

Ready to Take the Next Step? Let’s Talk

If you’re an FBI employee facing removal, suspension, or whistleblower retaliation, don’t wait—time limits apply. Our attorneys can determine whether you qualify for MSPB review, guide you through the internal process, and help you build a strong record for appeal.

Book your free consultation today: nationalsecuritylawfirm.com/book-consult-now

National Security Law Firm: It’s Our Turn to Fight for You.