The Digital Age Problem with Expungements
Across the country, thousands of people expunge their criminal records every year. Expungement is meant to provide a clean slate—so that old mistakes don’t keep haunting someone in job applications, housing, or professional opportunities.
But there’s a catch. Expungement orders usually apply to court files, arrest records, and law enforcement databases. They do not automatically erase references to those cases in published court opinions.
That means if you appealed your conviction years ago, the appellate opinion may still be sitting online for anyone to find. And unlike a dusty law book in a courthouse library, online opinions are searchable on Google, Justia, Leagle, or government websites.
The result? Even if your record is sealed, the opinion can still reveal your name and the details of your conviction to employers, colleagues, and the public.
At National Security Law Firm, we’ve seen this issue firsthand—and we are helping clients confront it.
What the Law Says
Every state has its own expungement rules. Most laws require courts, prosecutors, and police to remove or seal the original case records. But appellate opinions are a gray area. They’re considered part of the public record and, in many states, courts are reluctant to change them once published.
That said, some states have taken steps to align appellate opinions with expungement:
-
Indiana: If a person’s name appears in an appellate opinion and the case is later expunged, the court must redact the name in the online opinion.
-
Kentucky: Courts can, upon motion, reissue an opinion with the petitioner’s name removed.
-
Maryland and D.C.: These jurisdictions go the opposite direction, explicitly barring courts from redacting names in published opinions.
-
Most states, including New Jersey and New York: The law is silent. That means the issue is unsettled and can be argued on a case-by-case basis.
This inconsistency leaves many people stuck in legal limbo: their records are cleared, but their names live on in searchable opinions.
Possible Options
If your name appears in an online appellate decision after your case was expunged, here are the potential avenues:
-
File a Motion to Redact/Anonymize: Ask the appellate court to reissue the opinion using initials or a pseudonym instead of your name. Strong arguments include: (1) the expungement statutes require names to be deleted from records; and (2) the opinion has no precedential value if unpublished.
-
Request Administrative Removal: Some courts, especially for unpublished opinions, may honor a request to redact or restrict access without a full motion—though this is rare.
-
Leverage Persuasive Authority: Cite states like Indiana and Kentucky, which already allow redaction. Courts are more likely to act when they see other jurisdictions have done so without harming the integrity of the law.
Why This is a Novel Issue
No U.S. Supreme Court or nationwide ruling has decided this question. Many state courts have also stayed silent. That means motions to redact appellate opinions after expungement are novel legal arguments—uncharted territory.
At NSLF, we believe the argument is compelling:
-
Expungement statutes were written to give people a real second chance.
-
Leaving an appellate opinion online undermines that purpose.
-
Other states have shown it can be done without harming public access to the law.
Still, courts are cautious. They may see opinions as “historical truth” that shouldn’t be altered. Until appellate courts begin deciding these motions, outcomes will remain uncertain.
Why Choose NSLF
At National Security Law Firm, we thrive in unsettled areas of the law. Our attorneys are experienced litigators who take on novel issues head-on.
-
We bring deep knowledge of expungement and record-clearing law nationwide.
-
We craft creative, aggressive motions to maximize your chance of success.
-
We offer flexible legal financing through Affirm, making this fight affordable.
-
We maintain a 4.9-star rating on Google Reviews, reflecting our commitment to client service.
-
We represent clients nationwide, from our headquarters in Washington, D.C.
National Security Law Firm: It’s Our Turn to Fight for You.
Ready to Take the Next Step?
If your name still appears in an appellate decision after your record has been expunged, you don’t have to face it alone. This is a cutting-edge issue, and NSLF is ready to fight for your clean slate.