What the 2021 NDAA Says About Titling Removal

The 2021 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) introduced significant reforms to the military justice system, particularly concerning titling and indexing in criminal investigations. Titling refers to the process where a service member is named as a subject of an investigation, often resulting in their name being indexed in the Defense Central Index of Investigations (DCII). This can have long-lasting repercussions on their career, security clearance, and reputation—even if no formal charges were filed or the investigation did not result in disciplinary action.

Before 2021, the process for requesting the removal of a titling decision was limited, and once a service member’s name was entered into the DCII, it remained there indefinitely unless a rare exception applied. The threshold for being titled was low—simply the presence of “credible information” was sufficient, even if the case lacked substantial evidence.

However, under the 2021 NDAA, new provisions were introduced to allow for more favorable review and removal of these titling decisions. This was in response to criticisms that the titling process was overly punitive and lacked sufficient checks and balances. The key points of the 2021 NDAA regarding titling removal are:

  1. Right to Request Removal: Service members now have the right to formally request the removal or correction of their titling from investigative records if it is found that:
    • There was insufficient evidence to justify the titling decision.
    • No probable cause existed to sustain the titling.
    • Procedural errors occurred during the investigation process.
  2. New Standards for Probable Cause: The NDAA introduced a stricter review process in which probable cause is evaluated (rather than the lower “credible information” standard), allowing more opportunities to remove unjust titling decisions.
  3. Administrative Review Process: The law directs the Secretary of Defense to create and implement a formal process for reviewing and adjudicating requests for titling removal. This is an important change, as previously, there was no clear pathway for service members to challenge or appeal a titling decision.
  4. Clear Criteria for Removal: Removal is now required when:
    • Mistaken Identity: The service member was wrongly titled due to an error in identification.
    • Insufficient Evidence: If the evidence that initially led to titling was later found to be weak or nonexistent.
    • New Evidence: If new, exculpatory evidence comes to light that casts doubt on the initial findings.
  5. Retention and Removal of Data: The act also provides guidelines on when and how information in the DCII can be expunged or amended, depending on the findings of the review board.

Practical Implications for Service Members

The reforms introduced by the 2021 NDAA provide a more robust process for service members seeking to correct unjust titling decisions. Here’s how these changes affect service members practically:

  1. Easier Path to Correction: Before the NDAA, service members had limited options to challenge a titling decision, and once their name was entered into the DCII, it was difficult to remove. Now, with the right to request removal or correction, service members have a clear pathway to seek justice. This is particularly important for those who were titled without strong evidence or due to procedural mistakes.
  2. Impact on Security Clearances: Many service members and veterans rely on security clearances for their careers, both in the military and in civilian employment. A titling decision can negatively impact security clearance renewals or applications, effectively limiting career advancement or job opportunities. The new NDAA standards for reviewing probable cause mean that individuals may now have a stronger case for removal, preserving or restoring their clearance status.
  3. Rehabilitation of Reputation: Being titled in a military investigation, even without formal charges, can damage a service member’s reputation. The new provisions allow individuals to clear their name if there was an administrative error, mistaken identity, or if the investigation’s findings were unjust. This can be life-changing for individuals looking to advance their careers or transition to civilian roles.
  4. Faster Resolution: The NDAA mandates the establishment of a formal process for requesting titling removal, which means that the time-consuming and opaque procedures of the past are being streamlined. With a defined pathway to appeal, service members can expect quicker resolutions to their cases.
  5. Clarity and Accountability: The law now holds investigators accountable for adhering to stricter standards. This offers more transparency and fairness to those who have been unjustly titled, ensuring that investigators follow due process.

Why Choose NSLF for Your Titling Removal Case?

  1. Excellence in Military Law: At National Security Law Firm, our attorneys are former military prosecutors with extensive experience in handling titling and probable cause cases. We are deeply familiar with the new provisions in the 2021 NDAA and know how to use these rules to benefit our clients.
  2. Proven Success with Titling Cases: We have a track record of successfully navigating the titling removal process for our clients. Our expertise in military law, combined with the updated rules in the NDAA, allows us to build strong cases for those seeking titling removal.
  3. Personalized Legal Strategies: Every case is unique, and our legal team works with you to develop a tailored approach, whether your case involves procedural errors, new evidence, or unjust titling decisions.

Affordable Pricing and What You Get with NSLF

For a flat fee of $5000, NSLF offers comprehensive legal services for titling removal cases. This includes:

  • Thorough Case Evaluation: We review your case in detail to assess the chances for a successful removal.
  • Dedicated Case Manager: A personal case manager is assigned to ensure continuous communication and updates.
  • Flexible Payment Plans: With Pay Later by Affirm, you can break up payments over 3, 6, 12, or 24 months without impacting your credit score.
  • Priority Handling: We understand the urgency of these matters and ensure that your case receives the attention it deserves.

Call Us Today for Peace of Mind

Time is critical when it comes to titling removal. With the recent changes brought by the 2021 NDAA, you have more opportunities than ever to clear your name and protect your career. One quick call to the National Security Law Firm is all it takes to get started. Let us evaluate whether you have a strong case and plan the entire process for you, making it fast, easy, and affordable. Contact us today for a free consultation, and let us fight for your future.

For more details on how the NDAA impacts titling removal, be sure to visit our Comprehensive Titling Removal Guide for in-depth information and actionable steps.

For more detailed insights on titling removal, be sure to explore our related blog posts on this subject, including: